Generative AI Tobacco Reviews

FloydMindBender

Well-known member
I work with Generative AI and other emerging technologies fairly often and I thought some folks who enjoy the pipe and don't have any direct experience with AI might find this interesting (or not).

I fed the same prompt to the following AI Chat Platforms: Bard, Claude, and ChatGPT. Below are the responses generated by each platform.

PROMPT: "Write a 100 word technical review of Escudo Navy Deluxe pipe tobacco."

Bard Review
Escudo Navy Deluxe is a medium-bodied Virginia-Perique blend that is made with a combination of full-bodied Virginias and slowly fermented Louisiana Perique. The tobacco is pressed and spun, then sliced into coins. The result is a tobacco that is both flavorful and satisfying.

The Virginia tobaccos in Escudo Navy Deluxe provide a foundation of hay, honey, and citrus flavors. The Perique adds a touch of earthiness, spice, and plum. The overall flavor profile is complex and balanced, with a nice mix of sweetness and spice.

The smoke from Escudo Navy Deluxe is smooth and creamy, with no harshness or bite. The tobacco burns evenly and produces a long smoke. The aroma is rich and complex, with notes of hay, honey, citrus, plum, and spice.

Escudo Navy Deluxe is a great tobacco for both beginners and experienced pipe smokers. It is easy to smoke and produces a smooth, flavorful smoke. The tobacco is also relatively affordable, making it a great value for the money.

Here are some additional technical specifications for Escudo Navy Deluxe:

  • Strength: Medium
  • Nicotine content: Medium
  • Flavor profile: Sweet, savory, complex
  • Burn rate: Slow
  • Room note: Rich, complex
  • Price: Affordable
Overall, Escudo Navy Deluxe is a great tobacco that is sure to please both beginners and experienced pipe smokers. It is a flavorful, enjoyable tobacco that is also relatively affordable. If you are looking for a new Virginia-Perique blend to try, Escudo Navy Deluxe is definitely worth a try.

ChatGPT Review
Escudo Navy Deluxe showcases a meticulously balanced blend of Virginia and Perique tobaccos. The exquisite ribbon cut facilitates easy packing and even combustion, yielding a consistent burn rate. The Virginia imparts a subtle sweetness while the Perique adds a hint of peppery complexity. The moisture content is optimal, requiring minimal drying time. The nicotine strength is moderate, appealing to a broad range of enthusiasts. The tin note is inviting, and the room aroma is pleasantly aromatic. Overall, Escudo Navy Deluxe exhibits impeccable quality control, delivering a refined smoking experience suitable for both seasoned connoisseurs and those exploring the realm of pipe tobacco.

Claude Review
Escudo Navy Deluxe is a classic Virginia flake tobacco, produced by Danish company Orlik. The base leaf is a bright Virginia, expertly processed to retain maximum sugars and flavors. The ribbon cut flakes have a predominance of lemon and orange hues, indicating a high proportion of prized Orange and Yellow Virginias. The moisture content is ideal, with just the right amount of natural sugars remaining. It packs easily and burns cool and slow, delivering a consistent flavor experience. The natural sugars caramelize during combustion, producing a slightly sweet smoke. The balanced pH prevents tongue bite. Overall, Escudo Navy Deluxe exemplifies a well-crafted Virginia tobacco blend showcasing the rich, refined qualities of superior grade Virginias.
 

commonsenseman

Well-known member
I work with Generative AI and other emerging technologies fairly often and I thought some folks who enjoy the pipe and don't have any direct experience with AI might find this interesting (or not).

I fed the same prompt to the following AI Chat Platforms: Bard, Claude, and ChatGPT. Below are the responses generated by each platform.

PROMPT: "Write a 100 word technical review of Escudo Navy Deluxe pipe tobacco."

Bard Review
Escudo Navy Deluxe is a medium-bodied Virginia-Perique blend that is made with a combination of full-bodied Virginias and slowly fermented Louisiana Perique. The tobacco is pressed and spun, then sliced into coins. The result is a tobacco that is both flavorful and satisfying.

The Virginia tobaccos in Escudo Navy Deluxe provide a foundation of hay, honey, and citrus flavors. The Perique adds a touch of earthiness, spice, and plum. The overall flavor profile is complex and balanced, with a nice mix of sweetness and spice.

The smoke from Escudo Navy Deluxe is smooth and creamy, with no harshness or bite. The tobacco burns evenly and produces a long smoke. The aroma is rich and complex, with notes of hay, honey, citrus, plum, and spice.

Escudo Navy Deluxe is a great tobacco for both beginners and experienced pipe smokers. It is easy to smoke and produces a smooth, flavorful smoke. The tobacco is also relatively affordable, making it a great value for the money.

Here are some additional technical specifications for Escudo Navy Deluxe:

  • Strength: Medium
  • Nicotine content: Medium
  • Flavor profile: Sweet, savory, complex
  • Burn rate: Slow
  • Room note: Rich, complex
  • Price: Affordable
Overall, Escudo Navy Deluxe is a great tobacco that is sure to please both beginners and experienced pipe smokers. It is a flavorful, enjoyable tobacco that is also relatively affordable. If you are looking for a new Virginia-Perique blend to try, Escudo Navy Deluxe is definitely worth a try.

ChatGPT Review
Escudo Navy Deluxe showcases a meticulously balanced blend of Virginia and Perique tobaccos. The exquisite ribbon cut facilitates easy packing and even combustion, yielding a consistent burn rate. The Virginia imparts a subtle sweetness while the Perique adds a hint of peppery complexity. The moisture content is optimal, requiring minimal drying time. The nicotine strength is moderate, appealing to a broad range of enthusiasts. The tin note is inviting, and the room aroma is pleasantly aromatic. Overall, Escudo Navy Deluxe exhibits impeccable quality control, delivering a refined smoking experience suitable for both seasoned connoisseurs and those exploring the realm of pipe tobacco.

Claude Review
Escudo Navy Deluxe is a classic Virginia flake tobacco, produced by Danish company Orlik. The base leaf is a bright Virginia, expertly processed to retain maximum sugars and flavors. The ribbon cut flakes have a predominance of lemon and orange hues, indicating a high proportion of prized Orange and Yellow Virginias. The moisture content is ideal, with just the right amount of natural sugars remaining. It packs easily and burns cool and slow, delivering a consistent flavor experience. The natural sugars caramelize during combustion, producing a slightly sweet smoke. The balanced pH prevents tongue bite. Overall, Escudo Navy Deluxe exemplifies a well-crafted Virginia tobacco blend showcasing the rich, refined qualities of superior grade Virginias.
You're telling me a computer wrote this witchcraft?!?
 

owl

Well-known member
Plus one point for using the term "hay"; minus ten points for failing to use any of "grassy earthy woody floral bready or 'stewed fruit'".

Minus ten points for failing to tell me if this is an all-day smoke.

Minus twenty points for failing to use the term "sublimates".

Conclusion: better than most of the existing reviews on TR.
 

FloydMindBender

Well-known member
Next up, Captain Black Grape!!!
Prompt:
Write a 100 word technical review of Captain Black Grape pipe tobacco.

ChatGPT Reply:
Captain Black Grape pipe tobacco offers a rich and aromatic smoking experience. The blend features a balanced mixture of high-quality Virginia and Burley tobaccos, accented with a sweet and natural grape flavor. The tobacco burns evenly, producing a smooth and mild smoke that is pleasant on the palate. The grape essence is subtle, enhancing the overall flavor profile without overpowering the tobacco base. The cut is consistent, allowing for easy packing and lighting. While some may find the grape aroma appealing, others might prefer a more traditional blend. Overall, Captain Black Grape provides a unique twist on classic pipe tobacco.
 

SubComMarcos

Professional Relaxer
Honestly, I'm quite impressed with the quality of the reviews generated. I've noticed that Amazon has started using AI to summarize the reviews on some products and I've actually found it pretty accurate; the impression I get after reading 10-20 reviews matches well with the AI summary. However, there's a dead giveaway that one of the reviews above was generated by software:
Captain Black Grape pipe tobacco...accented with a sweet and natural grape flavor.

I refuse to accept that any actual human would refer to that flavor as natural grape.
 

FloydMindBender

Well-known member
Of the three--Bard, Claude, and ChatGPT--which "reviewer" aligns more with your preferences?
Generally speaking, all of these three, and some of the others, have different profiles. Some of them have more current training data for example, so I would go to them for something a little more cutting edge. Some of them have been designed in a way that I would say make them "better" or more natural writers. I will use different platforms depending on what I want to do with the tools. Most of the time I will run a prompt through multiple platforms and evaluate.
 

SmokeRings

Elitist Bastard
Patron
Prompt:
Write a 100 word technical review of Captain Black Grape pipe tobacco.

ChatGPT Reply:
Captain Black Grape pipe tobacco offers a rich and aromatic smoking experience. The blend features a balanced mixture of high-quality Virginia and Burley tobaccos, accented with a sweet and natural grape flavor. The tobacco burns evenly, producing a smooth and mild smoke that is pleasant on the palate. The grape essence is subtle, enhancing the overall flavor profile without overpowering the tobacco base. The cut is consistent, allowing for easy packing and lighting. While some may find the grape aroma appealing, others might prefer a more traditional blend. Overall, Captain Black Grape provides a unique twist on classic pipe tobacco.
Now I know for sure no actual human wrote this, it says CB is using high quality VIRGINIAS and burley, and that it has a natural grape flavor...nobody who ever smoked that blend would use those words
 
Top Bottom