@blackmouth210 OK...as promised. The valet arrived yesterday and I've had enough time to take it for a test drive.
(+) The marketing piece for this promised black walnut as the wood. I confess to having been a little skeptical, but it
is walnut. And it's a handsome piece, to boot.
(+) The machining and finishing rates a solid B+. The thing appears to have been made with precision. The finish is a satin (photo will confirm).
(+) The price was appealing: $30.
(+) The right-hand notch works fine for me. I'd thought that a left-hand notch might be a good option but now that I have one in hand it probably makes little or no difference.
(-) The piece is on the smaller side. The smallest notch will accommodate a Bic lighter standing on end, but it won't fit any other way. The medium-sized area is fine for a plug knife or matches...not much else.
(-) A pipe will fit in the medium-sized area but not too comfortably.
(-) A minor issue is that the whole piece is very slightly cupped, meaning that it doesn't sit perfectly flat on my desk. Maybe after it acclimates to the office it'll settle down. If not, no big deal.
Given the above, I feel quite good about the purchase. Its primary use will be for cutting plugs and for shepherding errant bits back into their respective tins, jars or bags. It'll get the job done
View attachment 84119
and look good while doing it.